Controversial Vietnamese film being considered for Oscars

Controversial Vietnamese film being considered for Oscars

Spread the love

A controversial Vietnamese film that depicts a long Vietnam War battle is under consideration for an Oscar nomination, according to California Assemblymember Tri Ta, R-Westminster.

Ta wrote a letter, dated Oct. 5, to the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, the Beverly Hills-based organization that awards the Oscars during the televised ceremony in Hollywood. Ta asked that the film, “Red Rain,” not be considered for the Oscar category of Best International Feature Film. In the letter, Ta called “Red Rain” a piece of propaganda that “glorifies the Communist regime.”

“A lot of members of the Vietnamese American community are upset right now, along with many Vietnam veterans,” Ta told The Center Square. “The movie is produced by the Vietnamese Communist movement, and they really twist everything around. That’s an insult of the sacrifices of the American soldier and the South Vietnamese soldier who fought side by side in the Vietnam War.”

The film, which depicts the 1972 Battle of Quang Tri Citadel, was produced by the Vietnamese People’s Army Cinematography Unit, essentially making it a propaganda film, according to Ta.

The Alliance for Vietnam’s Democracy also called the film a “state-aligned production” and expressed concern that the film risked presenting a one-sided interpretation of the Vietnam War. Approximately 92 Vietnamese civil society organizations signed the letter written by the alliance, according to an Oct. 17 press release.

“Such recognition could marginalize other perspectives and experiences related to the Vietnam War,” the alliance said in the press release.

Ta told The Center Square Tuesday that the events surrounding the 1972 Battle of Quang Tri Citadel are misrepresented in the movie, skewing details of those 81 days in ways that favor the Communists.

“There are so many facts in the movie that are completely wrong,” Ta told The Center Square. “I want the Oscar committee to reject the movie.”

For the Oscars’ Best International Feature Film category, each country is invited to submit its best film for consideration. Then all active and life members of the academy are invited to watch the submissions. The 15 films that receive the most votes advance to the next round of voting.

Only five of those 15 movies advance to become nominees, according to the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences. Members then watch all five nominated films and vote for the winner, which is announced during the televised Oscars ceremony. The deadline to submit a country’s choice for Best International Feature Film was Oct. 1, according to the academy’s website. Preliminary voting is scheduled for Dec. 8-12, and the Oscars shortlist announcement will be made on Dec. 16.

Nomination voting goes from Jan. 12-16, and Oscar nominees will be announced the morning of Jan. 22. Voting for each category’s winners is scheduled for Feb. 26-March 5, and the 98th Oscars will be broadcast live on March 15 on ABC.

Representatives from the Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences did not respond to The Center Square’s requests for comment on Tuesday.

Some state lawmakers who sit on arts and entertainment-related committees were also unavailable on Tuesday, although Sen. Ben Allen, D-El Segundo and chair of the Senate Joint Committee on the Arts, said through a spokesperson that he hoped “that the process the Academy follows will nominate worthy creative showcases.”

Representatives from the Veterans of Foreign Wars, Vietnam Veterans Against the War and the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund did not respond to The Center Square on Tuesday.

“As a Vietnam veteran who fought overseas for freedom and democracy, I am deeply offended that this movie would be considered for a prestigious award,” said Ronnie Guyer, a Vietnam War veteran, in Ta’s Oct. 6 press release. “Many of us still carry the scars of the war, and 58,000 did not come home from Vietnam. Seeing our military service distorted into propaganda is shameful and insulting to every American and South Vietnamese soldier who answered the call to defend freedom.”

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

solar panels photovoltaics in solar farm

“Federal Policy Uncertainty” Blamed for Delay of Peotone Solar Farm; County Grants Second Extension

Article Summary: The Will County Board has granted a second permit extension for a solar farm in Peotone Township after the developer, Trajectory Energy Partners, cited "ongoing uncertainty regarding federal...
solar panels photovoltaics in solar farm

Will County Grants Extensions to Five Solar Projects Sold to New Developers

Article Summary: The Will County Board approved first-time permit extensions for five commercial solar projects across Monee, Crete, and Joliet townships, all of which were recently sold to larger energy...
WCO 2025-09-27 at 9.04.10 AM

Will County Board Approves Controversial Drug Recovery Retreat in Crete Township

Article Summary: The Will County Board has approved a special use permit for The Second Story Foundation to operate a long-term residential recovery program for men on a 68-acre horse...
District 114 Bus

Parents Voice Alarms Over Bus Safety, Lateness in Manhattan School District

Article Summary: Parents raised serious transportation safety and reliability concerns at the Manhattan School District 114 board meeting, including a harrowing account of a kindergartener being dropped off at the...
Meeting Briefs

Meeting Summary and Briefs: Village of Manhattan Board of Trustees for September 16, 2025

The Manhattan Village Board took steps to prepare for future growth at its Tuesday meeting, awarding a contract of over half a million dollars to extend water and sewer infrastructure...
Joliet-Junior-college.-Graphic-Logo.4

Joliet Junior College Honors Seven Long-Serving Employees Upon Retirement

Joliet Junior College Board of Trustees Meeting | September 2025 Article SummaryThe Joliet Junior College Board of Trustees formally recognized seven long-serving employees who are retiring, including Dr. Robert "Bob"...
Screenshot 2025-09-27 at 8.39.48 AM

Manhattan Police Department Promotes Garrison to Commander, Diaz to Sergeant

Article Summary: The Manhattan Police Department solidified its command structure with the promotions of William Garrison to the rank of Commander and Bryan Diaz to Sergeant, who were both officially...
Meeting Briefs

Meeting Summary and Briefs: Manhattan Fire Protection District for August 18, 2025

Manhattan Fire Protection District | August 18, 2025 Meeting The Manhattan Fire Protection District Board of Trustees focused on the future of its facilities and public safety at its meeting...
Screenshot 2025-09-27 at 8.36.16 AM

Village of Manhattan Honors St. Joseph’s Catholic School on its 100th Anniversary

Article Summary: The Village of Manhattan celebrated a major community milestone at its Tuesday board meeting, officially honoring St. Joseph's Catholic School for its 100th anniversary with a formal proclamation...
Joliet-Junior-college.-Graphic-Logo.4

JJC Board Approves Contract with Adjunct Faculty Union

Joliet Junior College Board of Trustees Meeting | September 2025 Article SummaryThe Joliet Junior College (JJC) Board of Trustees approved a new collective bargaining agreement with the Joliet United Adjuncts...
Screenshot 2025-09-27 at 8.36.16 AM

Manhattan Awards $547K Contract for US 52 Infrastructure Extension to Spur Growth

Article Summary: The Village of Manhattan has awarded a $547,449 contract to Speece Construction for a significant sewer and water main extension project along the US 52, Smith Road, and...
manhattan fire district graphic logo.3

Fire District to Address Safety at High-Accident Intersections with County DOT

Manhattan Fire Protection District | August 18, 2025 Meeting Article Summary: The Manhattan Fire Protection District will meet with the Will County Department of Transportation to provide data and seek...
Meeting Briefs

Meeting Summary and Briefs: Manhattan Township for August 2025

Manhattan Township Meeting | August 2025 The Manhattan Township Board took steps to address the growing interest in renewable energy at its meeting on Tuesday, August 12, 2025, by scheduling...
Screenshot 2025-09-27 at 8.16.09 AM

Manhattan Eyes Major Water and Sewer Rate Hikes to Fund Over $50 Million in Infrastructure Projects

Article Summary: To address aging infrastructure and prepare for significant future growth, Manhattan officials are planning more than $50 million in crucial water and sewer system upgrades, which will necessitate...
Joliet-Junior-college.-Graphic-Logo.3

JJC Board Approves Student Trustee Quorum Policy Amid Heated Debate

Joliet Junior College Board of Trustees Meeting | September 2025 Article SummaryThe Joliet Junior College Board of Trustees passed a controversial policy change allowing the student trustee to be counted...