Controversial Vietnamese film being considered for Oscars

Controversial Vietnamese film being considered for Oscars

Spread the love

A controversial Vietnamese film that depicts a long Vietnam War battle is under consideration for an Oscar nomination, according to California Assemblymember Tri Ta, R-Westminster.

Ta wrote a letter, dated Oct. 5, to the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, the Beverly Hills-based organization that awards the Oscars during the televised ceremony in Hollywood. Ta asked that the film, “Red Rain,” not be considered for the Oscar category of Best International Feature Film. In the letter, Ta called “Red Rain” a piece of propaganda that “glorifies the Communist regime.”

“A lot of members of the Vietnamese American community are upset right now, along with many Vietnam veterans,” Ta told The Center Square. “The movie is produced by the Vietnamese Communist movement, and they really twist everything around. That’s an insult of the sacrifices of the American soldier and the South Vietnamese soldier who fought side by side in the Vietnam War.”

The film, which depicts the 1972 Battle of Quang Tri Citadel, was produced by the Vietnamese People’s Army Cinematography Unit, essentially making it a propaganda film, according to Ta.

The Alliance for Vietnam’s Democracy also called the film a “state-aligned production” and expressed concern that the film risked presenting a one-sided interpretation of the Vietnam War. Approximately 92 Vietnamese civil society organizations signed the letter written by the alliance, according to an Oct. 17 press release.

“Such recognition could marginalize other perspectives and experiences related to the Vietnam War,” the alliance said in the press release.

Ta told The Center Square Tuesday that the events surrounding the 1972 Battle of Quang Tri Citadel are misrepresented in the movie, skewing details of those 81 days in ways that favor the Communists.

“There are so many facts in the movie that are completely wrong,” Ta told The Center Square. “I want the Oscar committee to reject the movie.”

For the Oscars’ Best International Feature Film category, each country is invited to submit its best film for consideration. Then all active and life members of the academy are invited to watch the submissions. The 15 films that receive the most votes advance to the next round of voting.

Only five of those 15 movies advance to become nominees, according to the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences. Members then watch all five nominated films and vote for the winner, which is announced during the televised Oscars ceremony. The deadline to submit a country’s choice for Best International Feature Film was Oct. 1, according to the academy’s website. Preliminary voting is scheduled for Dec. 8-12, and the Oscars shortlist announcement will be made on Dec. 16.

Nomination voting goes from Jan. 12-16, and Oscar nominees will be announced the morning of Jan. 22. Voting for each category’s winners is scheduled for Feb. 26-March 5, and the 98th Oscars will be broadcast live on March 15 on ABC.

Representatives from the Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences did not respond to The Center Square’s requests for comment on Tuesday.

Some state lawmakers who sit on arts and entertainment-related committees were also unavailable on Tuesday, although Sen. Ben Allen, D-El Segundo and chair of the Senate Joint Committee on the Arts, said through a spokesperson that he hoped “that the process the Academy follows will nominate worthy creative showcases.”

Representatives from the Veterans of Foreign Wars, Vietnam Veterans Against the War and the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund did not respond to The Center Square on Tuesday.

“As a Vietnam veteran who fought overseas for freedom and democracy, I am deeply offended that this movie would be considered for a prestigious award,” said Ronnie Guyer, a Vietnam War veteran, in Ta’s Oct. 6 press release. “Many of us still carry the scars of the war, and 58,000 did not come home from Vietnam. Seeing our military service distorted into propaganda is shameful and insulting to every American and South Vietnamese soldier who answered the call to defend freedom.”

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

MH 114 June 2

Manhattan School Board Approves Staff Changes, Healthcare Extension in Special Session

Manhattan School District 114's Board of Education approved several personnel changes and a healthcare extension during a special meeting Monday evening, conducting most of its business in closed session. The...
Frankfort-Village-Board-Meeting-Graphic

Frankfort Approves $1.3 Million in Bills, Including Annual Insurance Payment

The Frankfort Village Board authorized over $1.3 million in payments at its meeting Monday, with nearly half of the total amount covering the village's annual insurance premiums. Trustees unanimously approved...
Meeting Briefs

School District 114 June 2 Meeting Briefs

Staff Departures: Manhattan School District 114 accepted the resignations of Emily Corcoran and Caroline Pesa-Miller, both effective at the end of the 2025 school year. The board approved both resignations...
Meeting Briefs

Meeting Briefs: Frankfort Village Board for June 2, 2025

Wendy's Project Approved with Multiple Variances: The Village Board gave final approval for a new Wendy's restaurant at U.S. Route 30 and Frankfort Square Road. The project required a major change...
frankfort-park-district.1

Frankfort Park Board Holds Closed-Door Talks on Five Oaks HOA Dispute

The Frankfort Park District Board of Commissioners entered into a closed executive session on Tuesday, May 27, to discuss pending litigation concerning the Five Oaks Park parcel, signaling a deepening...
MH VB 5--22

Manhattan Board Changes Meeting Time, Limits Public Comment

Village moves to 5:30 p.m. start time and reduces speaking period from five to three minutes The Village of Manhattan Board of Trustees approved two ordinance changes Tuesday that will...
MH VB 5--22

Manhattan Challenges Neighboring Villages to Pop Tab Competition

Community fundraising effort for Ronald McDonald House expands to include multiple villages The Village of Manhattan has officially challenged neighboring communities to a summer-long pop tab collection competition benefiting the...
Meeting Briefs

Manhatttan Village Board Meeting Briefs

MUNICIPAL UPDATES Memorial Day Services Planned: The I Honor Banner Ceremony will take place Sunday at 10 a.m. at the Manhattan Township Building, 230 S. Wabash Street. The ceremony dedicates...
Frankfort-Township-Logo-Graphic

Frankfort Township Approves Employee Raises, Details Major Infrastructure and Service Projects

Frankfort Township employees will receive a 2.5% cost-of-living pay increase after the Board of Trustees unanimously approved the adjustment at its Monday, May 19 meeting. The move came as Supervisor...
MFPD-Logo-Fire District

Fire Station Construction Bids Due June 3, Storm Generates 40 Emergency Calls

The Manhattan Fire Protection District has received strong interest from contractors for its new fire station project, with construction bids due back June 3 and groundbreaking still targeted for July....
Frankfort-Township-Logo-Graphic

New High-End Bar ‘Ace & Vine’ Gets Green Light from Township Board

A new bar focused on high-end liquor and an extensive wine collection is one step closer to opening in Frankfort Township after the Board of Trustees voted to recommend a...
MFPD-Logo-Fire District

Fire District Maintains Strong Call Volume, Equipment Readiness

The Manhattan Fire Protection District is maintaining steady emergency response capabilities while addressing routine equipment maintenance needs across its two-station operation. Deputy Chief Dave Piper's April operational report showed continued...
Frankfort-Township-Logo-Graphic

Golf Carts Not Permitted on Township Roads, Supervisor Clarifies

Residents hoping to drive golf carts on roads in unincorporated Frankfort Township are out of luck, as the practice is illegal under state law, Supervisor Nick George clarified at the...
Frankfort-Township-Logo-Graphic

Meeting Briefs: Frankfort Township Board for May 19, 2025

The Frankfort Township Board approved a 2.5% cost-of-living raise for its employees and discussed several major projects at its meeting on Monday, May 19. Supervisor Nick George announced that the...
MFPD-Logo-Fire District

Fire District May 19 Board Meeting Briefs

Board Actions Delayed: The swearing-in of new Trustee Mike Shivers was postponed until the next board meeting. The board voted to retain current leadership positions rather than reorganizing roles. Records...