WCO Board Aug 21.4

After Initial Rejection and Tense Debate, Board Reconsiders and Approves Contested DuPage Township Business

Article Summary: In a rare reversal, the Will County Board approved a special use permit for a landscaping business in a residential area of DuPage Township after the measure initially failed. The debate centered on whether to grant a special use permit or require a more permanent map amendment to industrial zoning, highlighting a conflict between following zoning precedent and addressing a unique land use situation.

DuPage Township Zoning Key Points:

  • Applicant: Roberto Mendoza of 17438 Bluff LLC sought a special use permit for a landscaping business at 17438 W. Bluff Road.

  • The Vote: The measure failed on an 11-11 tie vote before board members moved to reconsider, ultimately passing it 14-8.

  • The Debate: Members debated honoring zoning precedent versus making an exception for a property largely surrounded by industrial parks, with supporters arguing it mirrored an adjacent property and protected homeowners from permanent industrial zoning.

JOLIET, IL – A special use permit for a landscaping business in a residentially zoned area of DuPage Township was approved Thursday after a dramatic reversal by the Will County Board, which had rejected the proposal just moments earlier.

The request from Roberto Mendoza of 17438 Bluff LLC initially failed on an 11-11 tie vote, with County Executive Jennifer Bertino-Tarrant casting the tie-breaking vote against it. However, following a brief recess and a motion to reconsider, the board approved the permit on a 14-8 vote.

The debate highlighted a fundamental zoning dilemma. Opponents, including board member Sherry Newquist, argued that granting a special use permit for a commercial business in a residential zone was a dangerous exception.

“This is not something that is ever permitted in residential,” Newquist said. “And it makes it increasingly difficult to hold the line for future residential special use permits.”

The Land Use and Development Committee had previously recommended denial, favoring a map amendment to industrial zoning instead.

However, supporters argued the property was a unique case—an “island surrounded by industrial properties,” as board member Daniel J. Butler described it. The property is adjacent to industrial parks in Romeoville and Woodridge, and its direct neighbor operates a similar business under a special use permit granted in 2016.

“He’s just asking to be given the same rights as his neighbor,” said board member Jacqueline Traynere, who supported the permit. “I’m about fairness.”

Attorney John Simpson, representing the applicant, argued that a map amendment would permanently zone the property as industrial, making it difficult to ever revert to residential use and potentially harming nearby homeowners. By granting a special use permit, the business use would end if the property is sold.

Ultimately, a majority of the board was persuaded that the special use permit provided a necessary buffer for nearby residential subdivisions while accommodating the business in a practical way.

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

Trump: Zelenskyy could end Russia-Ukraine war ‘if he wants to’

Trump: Zelenskyy could end Russia-Ukraine war ‘if he wants to’

By Caroline BodaThe Center Square Ahead of the summit with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and other European leaders in Washington on Monday, President Donald Trump said Ukraine should give up...
$750 million facility to protect Texas cattle, wildlife from screwworm threat

$750 million facility to protect Texas cattle, wildlife from screwworm threat

By Bethany BlankleyThe Center Square Responding to calls by state lawmakers and the agricultural industry for immediate action to be taken to protect cattle and wildlife from a parasitic fly,...
Chicago posts fewest homicides since 2016, arrests rate also declines

Chicago posts fewest homicides since 2016, arrests rate also declines

By Glenn Minnis | The Center Square contributorThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Illinois state Rep. Kam Buckner, D-Chicago, studies Chicago’s somewhat mixed-bag crime trend data with little question...
Three years later, Inflation Reduction Act blamed for higher Medicare costs

Three years later, Inflation Reduction Act blamed for higher Medicare costs

By Tom JoyceThe Center Square This past weekend marked the third anniversary of the Inflation Reduction Act, signed into law by former President Joe Biden in 2022. While the law...
Illinois quick hits: Prosecutors charge two more in Tren de Aragua case; Senate Energy and Public Utilities Committee meets today; Illinois Little League team loses in World Series

Illinois quick hits: Prosecutors charge two more in Tren de Aragua case; Senate Energy and Public Utilities Committee meets today; Illinois Little League team loses in World Series

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square Prosecutors charge two more in Tren de Aragua case State prosecutors have charged two more migrants as part of an investigation...
Report: Human Rights Campaign pressures transgender procedures on minors

Report: Human Rights Campaign pressures transgender procedures on minors

By Tate MillerThe Center Square (By Tate Miller) – The Human Rights Campaign pressures children’s hospitals into performing transgender procedures on minors, according to a Do No Harm report. Do...
Everyday Economics: Housing market and Fed policy in focus in the week ahead

Everyday Economics: Housing market and Fed policy in focus in the week ahead

By Orphe DivounguyThe Center Square This week brings crucial updates on America's housing market struggles and hints about where interest rates might head next. Housing Data Dump Several major housing...
Meeting Briefs

Meeting Summary and Briefs: Manhattan Fire Protection District Board of Trustees for July 11, 2025

At a special meeting on July 11, the Manhattan Fire Protection District Board of Trustees took decisive action to advance its new fire station project. The board moved forward with...
Exec Cmte 8.14.25.3

Executive Committee Considers $12,000 Strategic Planning Initiative with University of St. Francis

Article Summary: The Will County Executive Committee is considering a proposal from the University of St. Francis to lead a six-month, $12,178 strategic planning process. The initiative is aimed at...
Businesses brace for new tax challenges amid global tariff focus

Businesses brace for new tax challenges amid global tariff focus

By Brett RowlandThe Center Square U.S. businesses and their partners across the globe are looking to make sure they comply with the highest import duties in decades amid a worldwide...
Illinois takes over health insurance marketplace in 2026 amid skepticism

Illinois takes over health insurance marketplace in 2026 amid skepticism

By Catrina Barker | The Center Square contributorThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Illinois will fully take over operation of its health insurance marketplace in 2026, moving away from...
WATCH: IL state reps challenge IEMA-OHS responses to local agencies

WATCH: IL state reps challenge IEMA-OHS responses to local agencies

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Illinois Emergency Management Agency and Office of Homeland Security officials are promising to be more responsive to...
Judge expands restraining order against 'Beto' O’Rourke, adds ActBlue

Judge expands restraining order against ‘Beto’ O’Rourke, adds ActBlue

By Bethany BlankleyThe Center Square A judge has expanded a temporary restraining order against former U.S. Rep. Robert (Beto) O’Rourke and his organization, Powered by People, as well as ActBlue...
Exec Cmte 8.14.25.2

Executive Committee Members Decry Roadside Litter, Call for Action Against Garbage Haulers

Article Summary: Will County Executive Committee members expressed frustration over what they described as a worsening problem of litter blowing from garbage trucks across the county. Members called for better...
Reversing Biden’s precedent, students complete FAFSA in minutes at beta-testing event

Reversing Biden’s precedent, students complete FAFSA in minutes at beta-testing event

By Tate MillerThe Center Square President Donald Trump’s Department of Education is working to restore the student aid FAFSA form after the Biden administration made what should be a couple-minute...