Appeals court: Serious Chicago police disciplinary hearings must be public

Appeals court: Serious Chicago police disciplinary hearings must be public

(The Center Square) – A panel of appellate court judges has ruled Chicago police officers facing serious misconduct allegations must have their hearings heard in public. A law school professor says it’s a victory, but just the beginning.

University of Chicago Law School professor and Civil Rights and Police Accountability Project founder Craig Futterman said a panel of appellate court judges made the only decision they could in upholding a lower court’s ruling stipulating that all Chicago police officers facing serious misconduct allegations must have their hearings heard in public.

“Holding these hearings in secret destroys public trust,” Futterman told The Center Square. “People don’t trust what they can’t see and a very first principle of policing is that we as police officers work for the public, serve the public and are accountable to the public. Among the lessons that have long been learned is that accountable and transparent policing is essential for public safety.”

In a move that upholds a Cook County judge’s earlier ruling, the panel of three judges cited “police accountability and transparency” concerns in rendering their decision. At the same time, the ruling allows officers to continue having their fate decided by an arbitrator as opposed to Chicago Police Board members.

If upheld, the ruling could mean big changes for the system after more than six decades of officers facing such disciplinary proceedings having their fates wholly decided by board members.

Futterman is quick to add there is still much work to be done in the name of greater transparency and accountability.

“One ruling doesn’t solve all our problems,” he said. “If the court did not stand up and speak up to protect police accountability and transparency, we’d be in a heap of trouble. We would essentially be undermining any form of police accountability and transparency in Chicago and in the state of Illinois.”

In the end, Futterman said such policy is a win-win situation for all the parties involved.

“If you protect the minority of officers who are abusive or racist and are acting as bullies or abusing their powers, people aren’t going to trust the 80-90% who aren’t doing that stuff because the message that sends to the public is the real police are those officers who are protected,” he said. “That’s not in the interest of the officers I admire and respect.”

Thus far in 2025, the Police Board has heard just one case and in two others Chicago taxpayers have been forced to pay out at least $12.75 million to resolve misconduct related lawsuits.

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

WCO-Landfill-8.5.25.1

Will County Receives Detailed Update on Landfill Expansion Investigation

Article Summary: The Will County Landfill Committee received a comprehensive technical update on the site investigation for the planned horizontal expansion of the county landfill, confirming the project remains on...
Meeting Briefs

Meeting Summary and Briefs: Will County Landfill Committee for August 7, 2025

The Will County Landfill Committee on Thursday heard a detailed technical update on the ongoing investigation for the county landfill expansion, confirming that the complex project remains on schedule. Consultants...
Green-Garden-Logo.WP

Green Garden Township Moves Forward with New Town Hall Plans, Awaits Grant Approval

ARTICLE SUMMARY: Green Garden Township is advancing with preliminary work for a new town hall, having met with architects and a civil engineer, while awaiting Will County's final approval to...
Green-Garden-Township-Graphic.1

Township Board Approves Budget Transfers to Fund Assessor’s Staff and Correct Rent Payment

ARTICLE SUMMARY: The Green Garden Township Board approved Resolution 2025-005, which reallocates a total of $25,200 within the town fund to provide necessary staffing funds for the assessor's office and to...
solar panels photovoltaics in solar farm

County Rep Cites Solar Lawsuits, Grant Shortfalls as Key Issues Facing Will County

ARTICLE SUMMARY: Will County Board member Sherry Newquist reported that the county is navigating lawsuits related to solar farm approvals and anticipating budget challenges from the loss of federal grant money....
Assessor

Assessor’s Office Hires Staff to Handle Workload After 6% Multiplier Hits Property Owners

ARTICLE SUMMARY: Following the application of a 6% property assessment multiplier across Green Garden Township, the assessor's office has hired a new staff member to help manage the increased workload and...
SSUCv3H4sIAAAAAAAACnSRz07DMAzG70i8Q5XzKpY10I0jB248wcTBdcwaLUum/AGhae9O0rQjB7jFP9uf/cWX+7umYQN4hey5ueQoxUrr6IODoKxJeL2auSMjydWEpArWKdA1HCDgaOBECZqodcbXKcl8gBA9+TxsRgiBDkmjwJtE2Whf4mZJTMnUkVKMrSrm4zCxBRXxfzpfoleGvH94VQYM0l9Kb8ojaQ2GbPS/suXxvliFAxn8ntxULh1pguJyX0rZ8SuQO9W+IUplK8ufFkHngq5SOjuFyhyqNhvG6QRLG9pogssr3D6EaWvPMOj8/x9JkxY+gvepXC68GoTp4PZUzTE2TAZmVSbTmXLIu023E6Lre7HlohNPYi4opx1V0pnWWYRSjEcla+sqb8AIibbYb1qOXLZih7wdeNe3m+6Ry4H3fECRPv76AwAA//8DAJrJGBCkAgAA

Township Appoints Temporary FOIA Officer During Trustee’s Leave of Absence

ARTICLE SUMMARY: The Green Garden Township Board appointed resident Belinda Olszewski as a temporary, non-paid Administrative Assistant and FOIA Officer to fill the roles while Trustee Sarah Boxer is on a...
Meeting Briefs

Meeting Summary and Briefs: Green Garden Township Board for August 11, 2025

The Green Garden Township Board pushed forward with plans for a new town hall and approved key budget transfers to support the assessor's office during its August 11th meeting. Supervisor...
Governor to evaluate tax proposal for Bears stadium in Arlington Heights

Governor to evaluate tax proposal for Bears stadium in Arlington Heights

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Gov. J.B. Pritzker is not ruling out tax legislation to help the Chicago Bears move forward with...
Illinois quick hits: Report shows rate of businesses leaving state

Illinois quick hits: Report shows rate of businesses leaving state

By The Center SquareThe Center Square Report shows rate of businesses leaving state Illinois businesses are moving to other states at triple the rate they did before the pandemic, according...
Report: New York No. 2 in nation for inbound tobacco smuggling

Report: New York No. 2 in nation for inbound tobacco smuggling

By Chris WadeThe Center Square New York remains one of the top states for inbound tobacco smuggling, according to a new report, which attributes the robust underground market to the...
Trump delays China tariffs by 90 days

Trump delays China tariffs by 90 days

By Andrew RiceThe Center Square The deadline to enact further reciprocal tariffs against China will be extended by 90 days, President Donald Trump announced Monday night. “[China] continues to take...
Kennedy visits Atlanta's CDC

Kennedy visits Atlanta’s CDC

By Kim JarrettThe Center Square U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. visited Atlanta's Centers for Disease Control and Prevention days after a police officer died in...
DCFS denies claim that agency uses uncertified interns to investigate families

DCFS denies claim that agency uses uncertified interns to investigate families

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – A state lawmaker says he has documentation to show that the Illinois Department of Children and Family...
Trump declares 'Liberation Day' in D.C., calls in National Guard

Trump declares ‘Liberation Day’ in D.C., calls in National Guard

By Sarah Roderick-FitchThe Center Square “Liberation Day” arrived Monday in Washington, D.C., as declared by President Donald Trump. The president declared a crime emergency in the district and said the...