Appeals court: Serious Chicago police disciplinary hearings must be public

Appeals court: Serious Chicago police disciplinary hearings must be public

(The Center Square) – A panel of appellate court judges has ruled Chicago police officers facing serious misconduct allegations must have their hearings heard in public. A law school professor says it’s a victory, but just the beginning.

University of Chicago Law School professor and Civil Rights and Police Accountability Project founder Craig Futterman said a panel of appellate court judges made the only decision they could in upholding a lower court’s ruling stipulating that all Chicago police officers facing serious misconduct allegations must have their hearings heard in public.

“Holding these hearings in secret destroys public trust,” Futterman told The Center Square. “People don’t trust what they can’t see and a very first principle of policing is that we as police officers work for the public, serve the public and are accountable to the public. Among the lessons that have long been learned is that accountable and transparent policing is essential for public safety.”

In a move that upholds a Cook County judge’s earlier ruling, the panel of three judges cited “police accountability and transparency” concerns in rendering their decision. At the same time, the ruling allows officers to continue having their fate decided by an arbitrator as opposed to Chicago Police Board members.

If upheld, the ruling could mean big changes for the system after more than six decades of officers facing such disciplinary proceedings having their fates wholly decided by board members.

Futterman is quick to add there is still much work to be done in the name of greater transparency and accountability.

“One ruling doesn’t solve all our problems,” he said. “If the court did not stand up and speak up to protect police accountability and transparency, we’d be in a heap of trouble. We would essentially be undermining any form of police accountability and transparency in Chicago and in the state of Illinois.”

In the end, Futterman said such policy is a win-win situation for all the parties involved.

“If you protect the minority of officers who are abusive or racist and are acting as bullies or abusing their powers, people aren’t going to trust the 80-90% who aren’t doing that stuff because the message that sends to the public is the real police are those officers who are protected,” he said. “That’s not in the interest of the officers I admire and respect.”

Thus far in 2025, the Police Board has heard just one case and in two others Chicago taxpayers have been forced to pay out at least $12.75 million to resolve misconduct related lawsuits.

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

Screenshot 2025-07-06 at 9.45.35 AM

District 210 Approves Administrative Restructuring, Staff Salary Increases

Lincoln Way Community High School District 210 board members approved administrative restructuring and salary increases for non-union clerical support staff during closed session actions Thursday night. The board unanimously approved...
Joliet-Junior-college.-Graphic-Logo.4

JJC Board Meeting Highlights Tensions Over Legal Bills, Trustee Conduct

An otherwise routine vote to approve monthly bill payments ignited a tense exchange at the Joliet Junior College Board of Trustees meeting Wednesday, revealing ongoing friction over redacted legal invoices,...
Joliet-Junior-college.-Graphic-Logo.3

Students, Trustees Emphasize Importance of Inclusivity and Flag Raisings at JJC

From a recent graduate’s public plea to trustee remarks on federal policies, the theme of student belonging and inclusivity was a prominent thread at the Joliet Junior College Board of...
Meeting Briefs

L-W School Board June 26 Meeting Briefs

Special Education District Update: The fence installation around the playground at Lincoln Way Area Special Education District 843 has been completed except for one gate section that will allow equipment...
Joliet-Junior-college.-Graphic-Logo.2

JJC Embarks on New 10-15 Year Facilities Master Plan Process

Joliet Junior College is laying the groundwork for its physical future, officially launching a comprehensive process to create a new facilities master plan that will guide campus development for the...
Meeting Briefs

Meeting Summary: Joliet Junior College Board of Trustees for June 25, 2025

The Joliet Junior College Board of Trustees met on Wednesday, June 25, 2025. Key actions included the approval of the fiscal year 2026 budget after a contentious debate and hearing...
Will-County-Board-Meeting-June-18-2025

Will County Board Halts Transportation Plan After Contentious 143rd Street Debate

The Will County Board voted Wednesday to send its five-year, multi-million dollar transportation improvement plan back to committee, effectively pausing all projects after a lengthy and heated debate over the...
Will-County-Board-Meeting-June-18-2025

Will County Board Upholds Zoning Denials, Rejecting Developer Appeals

The Will County Board on Wednesday backed its Planning and Zoning Commission (PZC), denying two separate appeals from property owners who sought to overturn the commission’s recommendations against their projects....
Will-County-Board-Meeting-June-18-2025

Split Vote Halts Monee Truck Terminal Project

A proposed truck terminal on vacant land at West Monee-Manhattan Road in Monee Township was stopped in its tracks Wednesday after the Will County Board delivered a split decision on...
Will-County-Board-Meeting-June-18-2025

Future Quarry Fight Looms as Board Approves ‘Tequila Barrel’ Retreat

While the Will County Board greenlit a unique tourist destination featuring overnight stays in repurposed tequila barrels, it also received formal notice of a coming fight to shut down a...
Meeting Briefs

News Briefs from the Will County Board June 18 Meeting

Monee Church Designated Historic LandmarkThe Will County Board unanimously voted to designate St. Paul's United Church of Christ in Monee as a historical landmark. Member Judy Ogalla, a Monee native,...
MH VB 6-17

Manhattan Police Department Welcomes New Full-Time Officer

The Village of Manhattan swore in Officer Joselyn Esparza as its newest full-time police officer during the June 17 village board meeting, bringing the department to full staffing levels. Mayor...
MH VB 6-17

Village Approves New Truck Purchase for Public Works Department

The Manhattan Village Board approved the purchase of a new Ford F450 truck for $116,000 to replace aging equipment in the public works department. The truck will be used for...
Meeting Briefs

Manhattan Village Board Briefs

Bank Letters of Credit: The board approved a resolution rescinding demand for payment on certain letters of credit for Banks Farm Development's Villas of Prairie Trails project. The bank provided...
Frankfort-Village-Board-Meeting-Graphic-June-16-2025

Frankfort Approves Outdoor Patios for The Loft and Grounded Coffee Bar, Waives All Parking Requirements

Downtown Frankfort is set to expand its outdoor dining options after the Village Board on Monday approved plans for new patios at two adjacent businesses, The Loft and Grounded Coffee...